Keep knowledgeable with free updates
Merely signal as much as the UK tax myFT Digest — delivered on to your inbox.
Small companies are liable for the overwhelming majority of tax evasion within the UK however HM Income & Customs doesn’t have a method to fight the issue, in response to the parliamentary spending watchdog.
In a brand new report centered on tax evasion within the retail sector, the Nationwide Audit Workplace has highlighted scams by companies that under-declare their revenue or artificially file for insolvency to keep away from tax payments earlier than relaunching as “phoenix” corporations conducting the identical enterprise.
“Though tax evasion has been rising amongst small companies, HMRC has to date lacked an efficient strategic response,” mentioned Gareth Davies, head of the NAO, which launched its report on Monday.
The Labour occasion, which gained energy in July, has pledged to boost an additional £5bn a yr for the general public coffers by 2029-30 by tackling tax dodging.
HMRC estimates tax evasion by small companies rose to £4.4bn in 2022-23, accounting for 81 per cent of the whole in comparison with 66 per cent in 2019-20.
The tax authority has a method for tackling all types of non-compliance, together with these attributable to taxpayer errors, however doesn’t have a selected concentrate on tackling evasion.
“This implies there was too little emphasis on some widespread types of tax evasion within the retail sector,” the NAO mentioned.
The watchdog highlighted scams equivalent to digital gross sales suppression, the place retailers use software program to cut back the recorded worth of transactions and current artificially low revenues. Different variations of the rip-off contain producing “dummy” units of accounts or operating tills in coaching mode to cut back taxable income.
These scams value the exchequer £450mn a yr, in response to a 2019 HMRC estimate. The authority estimated “phoenix” corporations accounted for greater than £500mn of tax losses in 2022-23 however the NAO famous the Insolvency Service had disqualified solely seven administrators for this follow previously six years.
The introduction of on-line firm incorporation in 2011 additionally made it “fast and simple to arrange UK corporations on-line from wherever on the planet, leaving the UK weak to tax evasion from fraudulent companies”, the report discovered.
A surge in new firm registrations forward of the introduction of tighter necessities at Firms Home, the UK’s company registrar, “might point out a doubtlessly greater threat of fraud within the retail sector”, the NAO mentioned.
VAT evasion by abroad retailers promoting on-line prices about £300mn a yr. However the NAO famous HMRC mentioned it had collected an additional £1.5bn a yr since 2021 modifications making on-line marketplaces accountable for VAT from abroad sellers.
The NAO report comes after official knowledge final month confirmed the variety of massive UK companies below investigation by HMRC for potential underpayment of tax has hit a five-year low.
“Tackling tax evasion isn’t a simple job,” Davies mentioned. “However actual alternatives exist for HMRC to work extra systematically throughout authorities to cut back it. Tighter controls and extra compliance work may increase important sums and enhance worth for cash.”
Paul Monaghan, chief govt of the Honest Tax Basis, mentioned: “For a lot too lengthy, the dialogue of tax avoidance within the UK has centered solely on multinational enterprises. Tax dodging by small enterprise is prone to be no less than, if no more, impactful.”
HMRC mentioned it raised a report £843bn in tax revenues final yr and works with the Insolvency Service and Firms Home “to sort out evasion in retail and on-line providers”.
“The UK has one of many lowest tax gaps reported on the planet, however the authorities is dedicated to decreasing it additional,” it mentioned. “Whereas the overwhelming majority of companies pay the tax that’s due, we are going to proceed to make use of our civil and legal powers in opposition to the decided minority who refuse to play by the foundations. Such motion helped us shield £41.8bn previously 12 months.”
Extra reporting by Emma Agyemang in Copenhagen
