The brand new 12 months’s first official buying and selling day was this Tuesday — and it was a tough one for the Magnificent 7.
Analysts from Barclay downgraded Apple’s (Nasdaq: AAPL) shares, questioning the corporate’s sky-high valuations (which I spoke about right here in Banyan Edge only a few weeks in the past).
The downgrade triggered a cascade of promoting that noticed tech shares lose over $235 billion in market cap earlier than the day was carried out. Apart from Tesla, every of the “Magnificent Seven” mega-cap tech shares dropped by 1% or extra.
In different phrases, 2024 began with one of many worst buying and selling days in months.
And it stored getting worse, with Roundhill’s Magnificent Seven ETF (Nasdaq: MAGS) shedding practically 5% in the course of the first week of the 12 months.
Shell-shocked buyers and monetary pundits appeared to reply with a collective groan and a “right here we go once more,” as fear unfold that the latest rally is likely to be coming to an in depth.
But it surely’s necessary to place this week’s inventory efficiency in perspective — as a result of it provides us an important glimpse at what may change into 2024’s greatest revenue alternative…
Magnificent 7 to the Rescue
On the silver display, the Magnificent Seven have been a posse of gunslinging cowboys who rescued a small city from mustache-twirling villains.
Within the inventory market, the Magnificent Seven have been the top-performing tech shares that rescued buyers’ portfolios in 2023.
These identical tech shares have been a number of the hardest hit by 2022’s downturn, and so they bounced again quick — with common returns of over 111% throughout the highest seven tech shares (Fb, Microsoft, Apple, Tesla, Nvidia, Amazon and Google).
Tech’s high seven mega caps now make up practically a 3rd of the S&P 500’s market cap. As I confirmed you in December, Magnificent Seven valuations are practically twice that of the S&P 500 Equal Weight Index:
Astronomical valuations for Magnificent Seven shares.
The Magnificent Seven are nice shares.
They usually need to command some sort of premium.
However at these valuations, there’s simply no room for error.
All it takes is one piece of dangerous information (this week it was a scores downgrade from Barclay’s) to ship shares tumbling from these dizzying heights.
We’ve seen it occur earlier than with overpriced EV shares, different tech shares — even Magnificent Seven shares. Fb (Nasdaq: META) fell 26% in a single day after information broke concerning the failure of Zuckerberg’s metaverse.
On the finish of 2023, Massive Tech shares have been primarily “priced for good efficiency.”
As if buyers assume all of this 12 months’s boldest AI predictions will inevitably come true.
If and when these projections fall quick, those that invested at at this time’s costs can be caught with the invoice in 2024.
I nonetheless advocate contemplating some stop-losses or different danger administration measures to your Magnificent Seven holdings.
These mega-cap shares aren’t prone to crash anytime quickly.
However the upside of investing in these shares is at present very restricted. And it pays to be cautious when valuations attain these ranges.
What In regards to the “Not-So-Magnificent” 493? The Consultants Weigh In…
It hardly comes as a shock to see buyers piling into the Magnificent Seven.
In spite of everything, high tech shares have been a few of this technology’s finest performers. Traders have discovered they will persistently depend on shares like Apple and Google for outsized beneficial properties.
Traders are additionally optimistic about fast developments in new know-how like AI — which ought to increase Massive Tech shares even larger.
However after 2023’s bear market, buyers are nonetheless considerably risk-averse. They need to follow well-known and “safer” mega-cap shares.
All of those components contributed to a “good storm” for high tech shares over the past 12 months, with a stampeding herd of buyers piling into the Magnificent Seven. Therefore their sky-high valuations.
Some consultants, like Goldman Sachs’ David Kostin, consider the Magnificent Seven will proceed to outperform in 2024.
Kostin factors out that there’s no actual return relationship between the Magnificent Seven and the opposite shares within the index.
So whereas it might sound pure to anticipate the opposite 493 will quickly catch up, Kostin argues there’s no clear precedent for it.
“There was no dependable historic relationship between the trailing and ahead 12-month outperformance of the most important seven S&P 500 constituents vs. the rest of the index,” he defined in a latest be aware to buyers.
Kostin pointed again to 2020 and 2021, two consecutive years by which mega-cap tech shares trounced the competitors.
Matthew Bartolini from State Road argues that we’ll see a change-up within the Magnificent Seven’s roster for 2024.
He believes Fb (Nasdaq: META) and Tesla (Nasdaq: TSLA) can be changed by a pair of recent high performers — ExxonMobil and Berkshire Hathaway.
“Given the way it’s extra possible than not that market breadth received’t be as concentrated in 2024, sector allocations are prone to rise alongside the elevated return dispersion,” Bartolini defined.
In different phrases, buyers have been extra targeted on surviving 2023 … the place they’ll be aiming to thrive in 2024.
Bartolini is onto one thing there, too.
Two Paths for the Magnificent 7 in 2024
As buyers regain their urge for food for danger, you may anticipate them to start out reaching for smaller and extra revolutionary corporations. These corporations’ shares are inherently extra risky than mega-cap tech giants, so that they’re able to a lot quicker beneficial properties.
And as soon as different buyers start to see and listen to about these fast-moving beneficial properties, you may anticipate the concern of lacking out (aka “FOMO”) to start out kicking in.
However I’m reminded of the knowledge of John Maynard Keynes, who as soon as stated: “The market can keep irrational for longer than you may keep solvent.”
Kostin could also be right…
In my view, Magnificent Seven valuations are already too excessive.
However as it’s possible you’ll recall, valuations reached a lot larger ranges in the course of the dot-com bubble (Nasdaq price-to-earnings ratios reached over 200 on the time!), so the Magnificent Seven may need extra room to run.
On the identical time, buyers are nonetheless anxious to see returns. They usually’re nervous about seeing one other downturn.
So it’s unlikely they’ll sit by way of many extra tough weeks (like this one) for his or her high shares with out beginning to contemplate various investments.
And proper now, there are many interesting options…
(You may be taught extra about my high “non-Magnificent Seven” investments HERE.)
To good earnings,
Adam O’Dell
Chief Funding Strategist, Cash & Markets
