Does January Really Set The Tone For The Year? Testing The S&P 500 January Barometer

The January Barometer is a widely discussed concept in financial markets, positing that the stock market’s performance in January can predict its trajectory for the remainder of the year. A positive January is believed to herald a bullish trend, while a negative January suggests a weak year ahead. This analysis focuses on the S&P 500, a benchmark index encompassing the 500 largest U.S. corporations, to determine whether the January Barometer has empirical backing since 1990.

Using a systematic backtesting strategy, January’s performance is assessed. If the closing price on the last trading day of January exceeds the opening price of the first day, the month is classified as positive. The strategy entails opening a long position at the start of February and maintaining it until the following January, with no stop-loss or profit-taking limits, reflecting a medium- to long-term investment strategy.

Analysis of positive Januarys indicates a steady growth trend, even during challenging market periods, including the flat performance from 2000 to 2010. On average, the returns per trade hover around $11,157, yielding an 80.95% win rate. Conversely, Januarys ending negatively yield erratic performance, resulting in deeper drawdowns and an average trade return of $6,557, or a 64% win rate, underscoring the lower effectiveness of trades initiated during a negative January.

While a negative January often correlates with diminished returns, it does not warrant bear markets for the entire year. Instead, such months suggest that short strategies could serve as hedges, allowing investors to manage risk more effectively.

In conclusion, while the January Barometer is not a definitive rule, historical data suggests its potential utility in guiding investment strategies.

Why this story matters